【堅離地政經・馮智政】全球評估中國教育第一，事實是否如此? 教育大學校長建議將一半教師培訓課程在內地進行。

馮同學好犀利，呢啲咁dry咁悶嘅話題都可以講得咁生動令我聽晒，你有料👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

馮同學太勤力！需要多休息，才可以走更遠的路。祝你及－班志同道合的年輕人，不但可以找到生活更重要努力發揮自己言論及分析能力。謝謝你們的分析和分享。

多謝！

Jacky 你而家係我聽得最多的youtuber 👍

又上了一堂好課。謝謝馮老師🙏🏻

馮同學一講教育就精靈晒，精神晒👍

❤❤❤❤❤

講解清晰👍🏼

馮老師好厲害，解釋得清楚易明，尤其對統計資料嘅演譯

Thanks 馮同學

多謝，多謝馮同學🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

馮同學， 資料詳盡，高清嘅分析👍。但請小心，正苦會覺得你喺度傷害緊角加果樽鹽，引起民憤🤣

多D休息👍👍👍

A very good reading and interpretation of the PISA report and beyond🙏

多謝HKer加油❤

Thanks for a wonderful breakdown 🎉

一個最多做假的地方，可信嗎？

太透徹👍

🙏thanks for info and support you.

以數據和明智來分析全球評估的可信性, 充滿學術和未來教育的國際視野呢~~👍👍

Very good introduction

👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏

👍

❤

Just a note - 19' 29" I believe Mr. Fung should refer to "State School", rather than public school 😉

👍👍👍好！

Waste gas. I talked to a 清華 EE professor and suggested his students are examination machines and good at studying from textbooks only. My 師弟妹 （a top 4 engineering university in US) can kill his students on independent research any day. His was speechless.
Education is not bound by textbooks only as quest for knowledge is infinite and endless.
Kids in US are assigned for presentation of their own research papers in primary schools. The Chinese students are pampered by their teachers on their thought and speech under the socialism.
If the Chinese education is that superior, the Hong Kong parents would send their kids to study there instead of UK.
Vote by the feet.

謝謝，👍👍👍

🙋‍♀️🙋‍♀️

多謝詳細的分析。

近年來關於教育大結構嘅最好嘅文章, 也說到統計學嘅一啲最基本嘅最本質嘅 分析方法

Thank you Mr. Fung. Your production is always well-prepared and balanced. British schools are the best, coming from someone who has benefited from a free state owned school. Private schools (ironically called public schools in England) are the dreamt choice of most middle-class parents, not just Chinese parents. But somehow, the performance is not necessarily better than state school, except that one can built up an old boys' network.

純粹以學術分數來排名，亞洲有出頭天，但祝人類好運。

中國教育出最多小粉紅。

香港教育開倒車

張校長為學生安全著想！

中國教育，8，90年代可能都不錯，之後就變成應試教育，萬事只為考試攞分，培養出大部分都係高分低能，冇思辨能力和合作精神，最出色不過係一個”精緻的利己主義者”。。。那些將小朋友送去國內讀大學嘅家長，完全不了解國內大學嘅內幕，齋睇國內大學教科書，水平都落後西方。

八股文 。。。 無得頂！👍

又要強調下 香港都係大灣區

馮同学，你最后講的會我聯想到"給19歲的我" 🤔

總括來講，怎樣教育一個有良知，誠實，有思考，有社會責任人才是。

好似靚過北京故宮😂

好似話 Swiss 無教育局, 完全靠 公民社會.

又一次提醒大家不是中國人或中國唔好. 而係ccp 不好😤才令到全世界都討厭中國.

中國的校外差異係好大的
實驗班好多都係網班 去睇好一些的學校的網課

全部靠刷題

中國的教育 只重成績係人都知

你估張教授唔知實情咩？！😅

31:12 Analysis D學生？Analysis 唔係動詞呀！

👏🏻👍🏻💪🏻💖🙏🏻😊🦘🇦🇺🦥

中國係數據污染就世界第一，出好多啱研究方法但係 misleading 嘅醫學研究，簡直為禍人間，但係你又冇佢辦法，最大問題係印度，東歐，第三世界都有樣學樣，出一大堆open access嘅假journal。

Hukou 應該係戶口，唔係學區？

民主，自由係口國係禁語點教

中共数據，教育都用幾盤數

衡水中學就是強國教育的典範，好不好見仁見智

有兩个国家，一个国家能夠俾最有能力的人成为領导，另一国家只会俾政治正確的人做领导! 就算有最好的教育制度，那這国家教育出來最聰明的人，最後会去了那? So which game will you play?

Cheating 😂

一孩政策？

馮同學，乜中共數據不是最出名作假佯？

中共，中共，被人害還中國-中國的，真有病？

又做假

乜鬼嗻，大陆Ｄ“实验”学校不过喺公校“私有”，教育局摞嚟收高价学费而已，同你讲嘅“研究”有咩关系？😂😂😂